LCP LCP LCP
Skip to content

 

Making decisions in a leadership role is hard. In today’s world, there are few easy choices. Most decisions can be argued from either side and are rooted in a mix of assumptions and incomplete data. Leaders must have the skills to sort through the all of the complexities and noise—and, ultimately, pick a path.

Navigating the complexities of decision-making

Nuanced decision making—navigating ambiguous trade-offs—is critical to effective leadership. Yet it’s not an intuitive skill for most. So how do effective leaders “navigate the gray?” How do they manage through that murky land where most decisions fall—because they impact a person, they didn’t have all the information, or the current difference in choices seems negligible but the future impact might have unintended consequences?

The answer lies in approaching complex decisions with both ownership (willingness to make a tough call) and openness (actively listening to opposing views). These two traits are difficult to display simultaneously, but they’re the key to navigating the gray.

The Corporate Executive Board survey sums it up well in their research: Effective leaders make decisions as “informed skeptics.” At Insight Experience, we’ve found that these informed skeptics have certain things in common:

  1. They apply judgment to analysis.

  2. They have a point of view.

  3. They listen to others.

A well-respected CEO of an IT services company (that I had the pleasure of working closely with for almost a decade) once confided to me that the decisions he made most easily often did not turn out well. Why? Because he wasn’t open and, therefore, missed the complex and difficult implications of his choices. On the other hand, he said the best decisions he ever made were the ambiguous ones he wrestled with the most. As a result of his experience, he has consciously cultivated his ability to own his decisions and still be open.

He’s learned—and our work has shown repeatedly—that being forced to navigate the gray improves the decisions you make.

Subscribe to Our Blog

Let's Talk

We'd love to hear about your leadership development goals.

Leave Comment

Recent Posts

Insight Experience Named to 2025 Inc. Regionals-featured-image
Insight Experience Named to 2025 Inc. Regionals
Click to view Insight Experience Named to 2025 Inc. Regionals

We’re proud to share that Insight Experience has been named to the 2025 Inc. Regionals: Northeast list,...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Leadership Confidence: Women Deserve Better Than Imposter Syndrome-featured-image
Leadership Confidence: Women Deserve Better Than Imposter Syndrome
Click to view Leadership Confidence: Women Deserve Better Than Imposter Syndrome

Leadership development is about equipping people with the skills, mindset, and confidence to succeed. Yet,...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
The Strategic Leader's Guide to AI: Adoption & Governance-featured-image
The Strategic Leader's Guide to AI: Adoption & Governance
Click to view The Strategic Leader's Guide to AI: Adoption & Governance

In the first post of this series, "The Leadership Imperative: AI Literacy & Adoption," we explored Level 1,...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
The Leadership Imperative: AI Literacy & Adoption-featured-image
The Leadership Imperative: AI Literacy & Adoption
Click to view The Leadership Imperative: AI Literacy & Adoption

I recently attended a leadership development conference, and every session that mentioned AI was packed—often...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Your Guide to Bringing Strategic Leadership to Life, Part 3-featured-image
Your Guide to Bringing Strategic Leadership to Life, Part 3
Click to view Your Guide to Bringing Strategic Leadership to Life, Part 3

At the close of a successful leadership development program, energy is high. The call to action was clear....

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Practical Tips for New Leaders: Working with Senior Leaders-featured-image
Practical Tips for New Leaders: Working with Senior Leaders
Click to view Practical Tips for New Leaders: Working with Senior Leaders

Note: This is the second post in the Practical Tips for New Leaders series. Head here for tips on running...

Category:-  Featured , Developing New Leaders

Learn More Click to view blog post
How Business Simulations Build Leadership Mindsets That Last-featured-image
How Business Simulations Build Leadership Mindsets That Last
Click to view How Business Simulations Build Leadership Mindsets That Last

As we wrap up the first month of 2025, it’s a good time to check in on our leadership mental models. In a...

Category:-  Featured , Business Simulation

Learn More Click to view blog post
5 Signs Your Organization Needs Strategy Execution Training-featured-image
5 Signs Your Organization Needs Strategy Execution Training
Click to view 5 Signs Your Organization Needs Strategy Execution Training

Every organization wants to operate at its peak, but even the best-run companies encounter challenges that...

Category:-  Featured , Executing Strategy

Learn More Click to view blog post
Top 10 Leadership Insights of the Year: Our Most-Read Blog Posts-featured-image
Top 10 Leadership Insights of the Year: Our Most-Read Blog Posts
Click to view Top 10 Leadership Insights of the Year: Our Most-Read Blog Posts

As the year comes to a close, we’re reflecting on the blog posts that captured the most attention and...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Mastering Leadership Presence: Building Trust Through Authenticity-featured-image
Mastering Leadership Presence: Building Trust Through Authenticity
Click to view Mastering Leadership Presence: Building Trust Through Authenticity

Imagine you’re in the audience at an all-hands meeting. Your company has big news: an acquisition, a merger,...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post